The 39 Features of Altshuller’s Contradiction Matrix
Editor | On 21, Nov 1998
Ellen Domb
+1(909)949-0857 FAX +1(909)949-2986
with Joe Miller, Ellen MacGran, and Michael Slocum
The contradiction matrix, one of the first tools of TRIZ, remains one of the most popular. (Ref.1) The matrix itself, and the 40 principles of problem solving to which it refers can be downloaded from the July, 1997, issue of The TRIZ Journal. The same issue has a tutorial article on how to use the matrix and the 40 principles. (Ref. 2)
One barrier to using the matrix has been the very brief statements of the features that are the lists of improving and worsening features. The following expanded list was prepared by comparing several different translations (ref. 3,4,5) and has proven useful in several test classes.
Explanation of the 39 Features of the Contradiction Matrix
|
No. |
Title |
Explanation |
| Moving objects | Objects which can easily change position in space, either on their own, or as a result of external forces. Vehicles and objects designed to be portable are the basic members of this class. | |
| Stationary objects. | Objects which do not change position in space, either on their own, or as a result of external forces. Consider the conditions under which the object is being used. | |
| 1 | Weight of moving object | The mass of the object, in a gravitational field. The force that the body exerts on its support or suspension. |
| 2 | Weight of stationary object | The mass of the object, in a gravitational field. The force that the body exerts on its support or suspension, or on the surface on which it rests. |
| 3 | Length of moving object | Any one linear dimension, not necessarily the longest, is considered a length. |
| 4 | Length of stationary object | Same. |
| 5 | Area of moving object | A geometrical characteristic described by the part of a plane enclosed by a line. The part of a surface occupied by the object. OR the square measure of the surface, either internal or external, of an object. |
| 6 | Area of stationary object | Same |
| 7 | Volume of moving object | The cubic measure of space occupied by the object. Length x width x height for a rectangular object, height x area for a cylinder, etc. |
| 8 | Volume of stationary object | Same |
| 9 | Speed | The velocity of an object; the rate of a process or action in time. |
| 10 | Force | Force measures the interaction between systems. In Newtonian physics, force = mass X acceleration. In TRIZ, force is any interaction that is intended to change an object’s condition. |
| 11 | Stress or pressure | Force per unit area. Also, tension. |
| 12 | Shape | The external contours, appearance of a system. |
| 13 | Stability of the object’s composition | The wholeness or integrity of the system; the relationship of the system’s constituent elements. Wear, chemical decomposition, and disassembly are all decreases in stability. Increasing entropy is decreasing stability. |
| 14 | Strength | The extent to which the object is able to resist changing in response to force. Resistance to breaking . |
| 15 | Duration of action by a moving
object |
The time that the object can perform the action. Service life. Mean time between failure is a measure of the duration of action. Also, durability. |
| 16 | Duration of action by a stationary object | Same. |
| 17 | Temperature | The thermal condition of the object or system. Loosely includes other thermal parameters, such as heat capacity, that affect the rate of change of temperature. |
| 18 | Illumination intensity * (jargon) | Light flux per unit area, also any other illumination characteristics of the system such as brightness, light quality, etc.. |
| 19 | Use of energy by moving object | The measure of the object’s capacity for doing work. In classical mechanics, Energy is the product of force times distance. This includes the use of energy provided by the super-system (such as electrical energy or heat.) Energy required to do a particular job. |
| 20 | Use of energy by stationary object | same |
| 21 | Power * (jargon) | The time rate at which work is performed. The rate of use of energy. |
| 22 | Loss of Energy | Use of energy that does not contribute to the job being done. See 19. Reducing the loss of energy sometimes requires different techniques from improving the use of energy, which is why this is a separate category. |
| 23 | Loss of substance | Partial or complete, permanent or temporary, loss of some of a system’s materials, substances, parts, or subsystems. |
| 24 | Loss of Information | Partial or complete, permanent or temporary, loss of data or access to data in or by a system. Frequently includes sensory data such as aroma, texture, etc. |
| 25 | Loss of Time | Time is the duration of an activity. Improving the loss of time means reducing the time taken for the activity. “Cycle time reduction” is a common term. |
| 26 | Quantity of substance/the matter | The number or amount of a system’s materials, substances, parts or subsystems which might be changed fully or partially, permanently or temporarily. |
| 27 | Reliability | A system’s ability to perform its intended functions in predictable ways and conditions. |
| 28 | Measurement accuracy | The closeness of the measured value to the actual value of a property of a system. Reducing the error in a measurement increases the accuracy of the measurement. |
| 29 | Manufacturing precision | The extent to which the actual characteristics of the system or object match the specified or required characteristics. |
| 30 | External harm affects the object | Susceptibility of a system to externally generated (harmful) effects. |
| 31 | Object-generated harmful factors | A harmful effect is one that reduces the efficiency or quality of the functioning of the object or system. These harmful effects are generated by the object or system, as part of its operation. |
| 32 | Ease of manufacture | The degree of facility, comfort or effortlessness in manufacturing or fabricating the object/system. |
| 33 | Ease of operation | Simplicity: The process is NOT easy if it requires a large number of people, large number of steps in the operation, needs special tools, etc. “Hard” processes have low yield and “easy” process have high yield; they are easy to do right. |
| 34 | Ease of repair | Quality characteristics such as convenience, comfort, simplicity, and time to repair faults, failures, or defects in a system. |
| 35 | Adaptability or versatility | The extent to which a system/object positively responds to external changes. Also, a system that can be used in multiple ways for under a variety of circumstances. |
| 36 | Device complexity | The number and diversity of elements and element interrelationships within a system. The user may be an element of the system that increases the complexity. The difficulty of mastering the system is a measure of its complexity. |
| 37 | Difficulty of detecting and measuring | Measuring or monitoring systems that are complex, costly, require much time and labor to set up and use, or that have complex relationships between components or components that interfere with each other all demonstrate “difficulty of detecting and measuring.” Increasing cost of measuring to a saticfactory error is also a sign of increased difficulty of measuring. |
| 38 | Extent of automation | The extent to which a system or object performs its functions without human interface. The lowest level of automation is the use of a manually operated tool. For intermediatel levels, humans program the tool, observe its operation, and interrupt or re-program as needed. For the highest level, the machine senses the operation needed, programs itself, and monitors its own operations. |
| 39 | Productivity * | The number of functions or operations performed by a system per unit time. The time for a unit function or operation. The output per unit time, or the cost per unit output. |
References:
- G. Altshuller, Creativity as an Exact Science,Translated by Anthony Williams. Gordon & Breach, NY, 1988.
- Ellen Domb, “Contradictions.” The TRIZ Journal, https://the-trizjournal.com, July, 1997.
- J. Terninko, A. Zusman, B. Zlotin, Step-by-Step TRIZ, Nottingham, NH, 1997.
- The Invention Machine Laboratory â„¢ version 1.4, Help files
- H. Altov (G. Altshuller pseudonym) And Suddenly the Inventor Appeared, Translated by Lev Shulyak, Technical Innovation Center, Worcester, MA, 1995.